CDJ's or Ableton Live

*organix*

New Member
Messages
27
Likes
0
#1
Easy,

I'm selling my Technics soon :)sad:)

I recently bought Traktor scratch, but its not working for me. I love the idea, but i can't get into it. I've been looking at what's next - i've got my eye on a pair of CDJ's (Pioneer 1000's mk3), but i've been reading more and more good things about Ableton.

With Ableton live, i'd like to be able to create hours of music on the fly using controllers etc, i wouldn't want to sit staring into a laptop the whole time, which is what's half putting me off (a bit of laptop staring is granted, but i want to have fun as well!).

Do you think i'm better off with CDJ's, or shall i look at the Ableton Live / Controller route, and why? Question to number 2 please Cilla.
 

sammys

Shelter Birmingham
VIP Junglist
Messages
1,338
Likes
0
#2
depends really mate, if you play out i'd say cdjs all the way (or turntables obviously), that way you can walk into any club and play without the hassle of setting all the extras up
also ableton does all the beatmatching for you which many people would look down on. It seems a waste of you spending years learning to mix just to switch to something which does it for you. You will also do a lot of laptop staring on an ableton setup
 
D

dirty breaks

Guest
#7
also ableton does all the beatmatching for you which many people would look down on.
why should he consider other peoples preferences for playing records?


It seems a waste of you spending years learning to mix just to switch to something which does it for you.
not really a waste, once you've got beatmatching mastered you don't need to prove yourself to anyone, and tune selection/eq'ing is more important than beatmatching anyway...

You will also do a lot of laptop staring on an ableton setup
and you will do a lot of vinyl staring on vinyl, starting at the bpm counter on cdj's, staring at your laptop on serato/traktor.
 

EvezDroppin

..
VIP Junglist
Messages
2,909
Likes
133
#8
hm contemplating the same here aswell... got 3 technics, wanting to go digital... traktor plus a laptop seems a pain but think im going to have to take the dive, altho if cdj's were cheaper i would go down that route
 
Messages
282
Likes
10
#9
Try both...Use what works for you.


Digital has more capabilities while CDJ's make you feel immersed. Personally...1210's and a stack of vinyl.. Mmm its just too good! If it ever came to a live sense I would definitely go with digital though.
 

Howitzer

Active Member
VIP Junglist
Messages
643
Likes
74
#11
digital (DVS) so youre not constrained to one medium.

Want to completely change your set in ableton on the fly? A bit more of a pain the butt than selecting another tune from your crate/box/bag/ass.

You could always switch out for a real vinyl/CD too if things go pear shaped.

Think of booth space also. Most places I frequent have trouble fitting in a lappy and a small midi controller, let alone a full APC 40 and whatever other midi bits you want.

As a producer playing your own stems to create live mashups and generally fuck up with too much beatmasher & flanger, ableton is great. As a DJ, I dont think it is so feasible.
traktor now has remix decks too, which could open up loads of ableton like possibilities without totally ditching DVS.

Why isnt traktor working for you?
 

sammys

Shelter Birmingham
VIP Junglist
Messages
1,338
Likes
0
#15
why should he consider other peoples preferences for playing records?




not really a waste, once you've got beatmatching mastered you don't need to prove yourself to anyone, and tune selection/eq'ing is more important than beatmatching anyway...



and you will do a lot of vinyl staring on vinyl, starting at the bpm counter on cdj's, staring at your laptop on serato/traktor.
calm down bud was just giving him my opinion, there are always gonna be people who look down on "digital", i get it loads and i use serato, hence why i also said there will be quite a bit of laptop staring as i do it myself
and in terms of the beatmatching, personally i wouldn't like to switch to something which does it for me after spending years perfecting it, but hey each to their own
so next time instead of just picking apart my opinion why don't you just reply with something helpful? :applause:
 
D

dirty breaks

Guest
#16
calm down bud was just giving him my opinion, there are always gonna be people who look down on "digital", i get it loads and i use serato, hence why i also said there will be quite a bit of laptop staring as i do it myself
and in terms of the beatmatching, personally i wouldn't like to switch to something which does it for me after spending years perfecting it, but hey each to their own
so next time instead of just picking apart my opinion why don't you just reply with something helpful? :applause:
I'll just use your own words against you.

instead of just picking apart my opinion why don't you just reply with something helpful? :applause:
 

*organix*

New Member
Messages
27
Likes
0
#17
Why isnt traktor working for you?
It's alright - been using it for about 6 months. I'm not too sure what it is i don't like about it to be honest, maybe its the thought of having to haul all the gear round when i play somewhere other than my house, maybe i was expecting a bit more from it. To be honest, i think i'm just ready to move completely off decks.

I wouldn't strictly be doing dnb with Ableton, i just like the idea of creating one sound, adding layers ,looping and messing about that way - i like the idea of how creative it is.

I've been looking seriously at CDJ's, just took an interest in Ableton recently, so far i've not received a shining recommendation about Ableton, so (so far) i'm heading for CDJ's

Nice one for your help up to now
 

Saint

Buried Audio
VIP Junglist
Messages
3,717
Likes
27
#18
If you're talking about using Ableton for something live as opposed to mixing its a complete different kettle of fish compared with CDJs.

That's more of a what do you want to be doing in a club, rather than a what medium do you want to use question.
 

OneSeventy

Well-Known Member
VIP Junglist
Messages
1,339
Likes
435
#20
I wonder how long CDJs are going to last. I can't see CDs as a format lasting for another 10-20 years even, not like vinyl which has lasted for ages. Someone (I think it may have been Kasra) was saying recently that they were struggling to even find blank CDs for sale (to be fair I think he was overseas at the time).

Surely the future is these digital controllers. Surely that's easier than burning tracks to CDs all the time. Surely it's cheaper too?
 
Top